Spotlight Review: CRUEL SUMMER by Maisey Yates

From the publisher:

A Contemporary Opposites Attract, Forced Proximity Romance of a Life-Changing Road Trip

There are no rules this cruel summer…

Samantha Parker has the perfect life—a loving husband, three wonderful kids and a comfortable suburban lifestyle. But on the brink of their long-awaited empty-nest chapter, Will asks Samantha for something she never dreamed of: an open marriage. Desperate to keep her husband happy, Samantha proposes a summerlong separation with no contact. She knows she has to use the opportunity to find herself, but she also has no interest in being with anyone but Will. She’s confident when the season is over, they’ll get back together like this time never happened.

Then Sam gets an adventurous offer from Will’s best friend, Logan Martin, a classic-car restorer. Logan and Sam haven’t had an easy relationship, but prickly Logan needs help driving across North America making deliveries. Among the winding roads and breathtaking backdrops, everything Sam thought about life is challenged—even her new connection with Logan.

But when summer closes, Sam has to decide: Will she go home to the familiar stability of her past…or choose the thrilling uncertainty of her future?

https://amzn.to/4j5KK0s

Samantha and Will were married young, high school sweethearts who found themselves expecting a baby before they even graduated. What started as teenage love endured for twenty years, through three children and a looming empty nest. Will had built a successful real estate business, and Sam created a successful work-from-home journalism career. Sam believed they were both happy with their life together. She was wrong.

When Will announces he wants an open marriage, Sam’s world crumbles. He confesses that he feels cheated out of the dating and sexual exploration that typically happens in one’s twenties, and he wants to experience that freedom now. Devastated but determined to maintain some control, Sam establishes firm boundaries: they will separate for the summer, neither will stay in their family home, and there will be no contact until fall. With their children already settled into summer plans, the stage is set for a season of reckoning.

Will leaves, and Sam is surprised to find Will’s best friend, Logan, at her door. Initially, she resents him—Logan lost his wife years ago and has been cycling through casual relationships ever since. In Sam’s mind, his lifestyle influenced Will’s sudden desire for an open marriage. But Logan surprises her by expressing his anger at Will’s decision.

Logan offers Sam an escape: a summer job helping him deliver restored classic cars across the country. His daughter usually accompanies him on these trips, but she’s staying at college for the summer. With nowhere else to turn, Sam accepts, despite their historically prickly relationship. After all, Logan is Will’s friend, not hers. She clings to the hope that once Will experiences his newfound freedom, he’ll realize what he’s lost and want her back. The question that haunts her is whether she will be able to take him back after knowing he’s been with other women.

As their road trip unfolds, Logan challenges Sam to examine her life with brutal honesty. Her world has been shattered, and she’s not even sure what to think about the pieces. Through Logan’s unwavering support and his insistence on complete transparency, Sam begins a transformative summer of personal growth.

But honesty works both ways. When Logan admits he’s harbored feelings for her since high school, everything shifts. Sam has always found him attractive—there was even a charged moment during a family vacation years earlier when she almost kissed him. But her commitment to her marriage vows held her back, and she deliberately maintained distance from Logan. Until now.

As Sam reflects on her past, patterns emerge. Logan has been present for her most difficult moments—her mother’s death from cancer, her decision to undergo preventative surgery—while Will was notably absent. On this road trip, she realizes she’s never been as authentic with Will as she is with Logan. Part of this stems from her upbringing in their small, Christian community, where her mother taught her to prioritize everyone else’s needs above her own—a lesson that has served her poorly.

This story resonated deeply with me. I experienced my own midlife crisis of sorts when I was around Sam’s age. While my situation differed—my husband was stalwart—I discovered important truths about myself when I took a part-time job at a bookstore after my daughter started kindergarten. I had been a stay-at-home mom for twelve years, so this was a major life change. I loved the work and realized I hadn’t been as fulfilled as I’d believed. My husband’s support throughout my journey of self-discovery actually strengthened our marriage, making us fall more deeply in love with one another. Sam’s path to her own happily ever after felt familiar and genuine. In fact, Sam writes a book about her experience, and this quote hit home:

Indeed.

I’ve enjoyed several of Yates’s previous novels, but this one struck a particularly personal chord. While it was emotionally challenging at times, I found it deeply satisfying. The story captures the complexity of marriage, friendship, and self-discovery with remarkable honesty. I loved it.

6/2025 Stacy Alesi, AKA the BookBitch

CRUEL SUMMER by Maisey Yates. Canary Street Press (June 24, 2024). ISBN: 978-1335471451. 320p.

Kindle

Audible

Comments are closed.